Get the latest on Wrath of the Lich King on WoW Insider!

Is 'An American Carol' a Parody or a Right-Wing Diatribe?

You may have heard that spoof veteran David Zucker's newest project, An American Carol, is a takedown of Michael Moore. You can now have a look at the trailer, online at Yahoo!. And then you can riddle me this: Does An American Carol look like a clever parody of Moore's documentaries, or just a partisan attack on the filmmaker? Or, put another way, is the clip of Bill O'Reilly slapping around Kevin Farley's "Michael Malone" a commentary on the rivalry between the two, or right-wing wish fulfillment? One thing to note before answering is that O'Reilly appears in the film himself, while Moore does not.

Moore is obviously fair game; I've enjoyed his films, and sympathize with (some of) his politics, but I'd eagerly watch a skillful spoof of the pudgy, faux-working-class provocateur. I think parts of the trailer are pretty funny ("Here I am on the island paradise Cuba!"). But if the point is just to pile on the guy, with a rah-rah patriotic, stop-hating-America message at the end, then I'm significantly less interested.

The thing is, the trailer really doesn't make clear what's going on. On one hand, prominent conservatives like O'Reilly and James Woods appear to deliver literal and figurative blows. On the other, "Michael Malone" gets accused of being a slaveowner, which sounds more like a parody of conservative attacks on Moore than of Moore himself. And is Trace Adkins poking fun at his image here, or is he for real?

We know that Zucker is himself conservative, and that the movie is political -- which is fine. But is it political in an incisive, worthwhile way, or in the brainless beatdown mode of Ann Coulter et al? What do you think?

Related Headlines

Reader Comments

(Page 1)
Next 20 Comments
NEWS
Awards (906)
Box Office (660)
Casting (4115)
Celebrities and Controversy (2042)
Columns (289)
Contests (245)
Deals (3402)
Distribution (1119)
DIY/Filmmaking (1948)
Executive shifts (101)
Exhibition (740)
Fandom (5447)
Home Entertainment (1397)
Images (886)
Lists (424)
Moviefone Feedback (6)
Movie Marketing (2612)
New Releases (2050)
Newsstand (4795)
NSFW (94)
Obits (318)
Oscar Watch (554)
Politics (877)
Polls (54)
Posters (236)
RumorMonger (2472)
Scripts (1766)
Site Announcements (287)
Stars in Rewind (88)
Tech Stuff (422)
Trailers and Clips (947)
BOLDFACE NAMES
James Bond (234)
George Clooney (158)
Daniel Craig (94)
Tom Cruise (246)
Johnny Depp (163)
Peter Jackson (137)
Angelina Jolie (171)
Nicole Kidman (60)
George Lucas (200)
Michael Moore (72)
Brad Pitt (173)
Harry Potter (190)
Steven Spielberg (312)
Quentin Tarantino (161)
FEATURES
Movies We're Thankful For (5)
12 Days of Cinematicalmas (60)
400 Screens, 400 Blows (129)
After Image (40)
Best/Worst (37)
Bondcast (8)
Box Office Predictions (103)
Celebrities Gone Wild! (25)
Cinematical Indie (4179)
Cinematical Indie Chat (4)
Cinematical Seven (307)
Cinematical's SmartGossip! (49)
Coming Distractions (13)
Critical Thought (349)
DVD Reviews (233)
Eat My Shorts! (16)
Fan Made (6)
Fan Rant (91)
Festival Reports (975)
Film Blog Group Hug (57)
Film Clips (36)
Friday Night Double Feature (40)
From Page to Screen (19)
From the Editor's Desk (69)
Geek Report (83)
Guilty Pleasures (28)
Holiday Movie Junk (23)
Hold the 'Fone (430)
Indie Seen (7)
Indie Spotlight (18)
Insert Caption (143)
Interviews (374)
Killer B's on DVD (80)
Monday Morning Poll (57)
Movie Games (2)
New in Theaters (328)
New on DVD (318)
Podcasts (126)
Retro Cinema (80)
Review Roundup (45)
The Scary Bits (14)
Scene Stealers (13)
Seven Days of 007 (25)
Summer Movies (45)
The Geek Beat (56)
The (Mostly) Indie Film Calendar (39)
The Rocchi Review: Online Film Community Podcast (41)
The Write Stuff (26)
Theatrical Reviews (1786)
Trailer Trash (482)
Unscripted (40)
Vintage Image of the Day (140)
GENRES
Action (5568)
Animation (1091)
Classics (1070)
Comedy (5070)
Comic/Superhero/Geek (2860)
Documentary (1422)
Drama (6202)
Family Films (1263)
Foreign Language (1609)
Games and Game Movies (320)
Gay & Lesbian (247)
Horror (2449)
Independent (3320)
Music & Musicals (975)
Noir (218)
Mystery & Suspense (942)
Religious (114)
Remakes and Sequels (4085)
Romance (1328)
Sci-Fi & Fantasy (3460)
Shorts (288)
Sports (295)
Thrillers (2013)
War (335)
Western (96)
FESTIVALS
Oxford Film Festival (2)
AFI Dallas (45)
Austin (24)
Berlin (90)
Cannes (335)
Chicago (18)
CineVegas (14)
ComicCon (138)
Fantastic Fest (86)
Gen Art (8)
Los Angeles Film Festival (9)
New York (56)
Other Festivals (303)
Philadelphia Film Festival (13)
San Francisco International Film Festival (28)
Seattle (66)
ShoWest (3)
Slamdance (22)
Sundance (618)
SXSW (280)
Telluride (81)
Toronto International Film Festival (439)
Tribeca (259)
Venice Film Festival (15)
WonderCon (1)
Friday Night Double Feature (1)
DISTRIBUTORS
Roadside Attractions (8)
20th Century Fox (682)
Artisan (2)
Disney (603)
Dreamworks (315)
Fine Line (4)
Focus Features (159)
Fox Atomic (17)
Fox Searchlight (188)
HBO Films (34)
IFC (134)
Lionsgate Films (443)
Magnolia (119)
Miramax (85)
MGM (205)
New Line (399)
Newmarket (17)
New Yorker (6)
Picturehouse (15)
Paramount (657)
Paramount Vantage (51)
Paramount Vantage (15)
Paramount Classics (49)
Samuel Goldwyn Films (14)
Sony (576)
Sony Classics (164)
ThinkFilm (117)
United Artists (42)
Universal (738)
Warner Brothers (1106)
Warner Independent Pictures (98)
The Weinstein Co. (493)
Wellspring (6)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

  • RSS News Feed
Powered by Blogsmith

Sponsored Links

Most Commented On (60 days)

Recent Comments

Other Weblogs Inc. Network blogs you might be interested in: